🔗 Share this article

Keir Starmer is facing internal dissent after ministers abandoned plans to provide employees day-one protection against wrongful termination, a U-turn that breaches the Labour manifesto.

MPs Voice Concerns

Lawmakers featuring a former minister who spearheaded the employment rights bill raised objections regarding the retreat announced by the government.

Ministers have axed the plan to eliminate the two-year waiting requirement for workers to make an unfair dismissal claim and permit them to act starting immediately in a new job, to facilitate passing the proposed law through government.

Legislative Deadlock

The proposal found itself in a standoff between peers and MPs regarding the initial proposal to give workers the protection immediately, along with provisions to prohibit abusive casual work agreements.

Ministers currently plan to establish the protection regarding wrongful termination following half a year employment rather, while other day-one rights to parental leave and sick pay remain scheduled to proceed, taking effect in April 2026.

Opposition and Condemnation

The Labour MP for Middlesbrough and Thornaby East labeled the action as a "total abandonment" and pledged to advocate for its cancellation.

"We are unable to endorse that partial approach."

"This constitutes flawed decision-making and I will campaign to have this concession reversed."

A different party representative voiced disappointment about the lack of consultation, observing: "There has been no discussion with party members. Peers shouldn't override over a manifesto commitment, therefore why did we surrender??"

Wider Consequences

A third Labour MP remarked: "Businesses should not worry about immediate protections, but workers have everything to fear from companies who opposes immediate protections."

The former employment minister confirmed that the decision "definitely is a manifesto breach."

Government Justification

The schools minister explained remained a "substantial likelihood" the implementation of the worker protection legislation would have been delayed had the administration not implemented a reversal concerning immediate safeguards against unfair dismissal.

"Consultation has occurred regarding the issue of wrongful termination and the qualifying timeframe among companies, trade unions and government, and subsequent to that dialogue there's been agreement regarding the path ahead, that represents positive development."

She emphasized that "Consequently the eligibility timeframe will come down from 730 days to 180 days, and that runs alongside significant first-day entitlements concerning illness compensation and around parental leave."

"However the danger present that if we didn't make progress, those significant entitlements might not be implemented from April next year."

Following inquiry concerning if it constituted an unfulfilled pledge, the official replied: "Within the election platform, the promise indicated was that we planned to cooperate with trade unions, with employers, with civil society, while discussing such entitlements we intended to implement."

"Therefore, two components exist regarding that matter, throughout the campaign document, the crucial protections and the consultation."